The Non-Compete Dilemma: What Employers Need to Know -...
How Can I help?

EverythingPeople This Week!

EverythingPeople gives valuable insight into the developments both inside and outside the HR position.

Latest Articles

The Non-Compete Dilemma: What Employers Need to Know

For years, employers have used non-compete agreements to protect their business interests, including confidential information, customer relationships, and trade secrets. However, these agreements have come under scrutiny more frequently as concerns grow about their impact on employee mobility, wages, and workplace competition. In 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) attempted to change the landscape by adopting a rule that would have prohibited most employers from entering into or enforcing non-compete agreements nationwide. However, legal challenges prevented the rule from taking effect, and the FTC withdrew its appeals and removed the rule in February 2026. As a result, there is no nationwide federal ban on non-compete agreements, and their use continues to be governed primarily by state laws.

For employers and HR professionals, this creates a complicated legal landscape. Some states prohibit non-compete agreements altogether, while others allow them under certain conditions, and a few with no restrictions. Understanding where these agreements are permitted, what makes them enforceable, and when their use can create legal risks is essential for employers looking to protect their businesses without unnecessarily restricting employees' future opportunities.

California, Minnesota, North Dakota, and Oklahoma all prohibit the use of non-competes meaning they do not allow any non-compete in an employment context. Several states have restrictions which may include compensation thresholds, ensuring there are no non-competes for lower paid or non-exempt employees. States may also enforce advance notice and procedural requirements and other statutory limitations or judicial standards like bans on certain industries. The Economic Innovation Group has a great interactive map tool to show you what legal restrictions exist for non-competes in each state. However, even in permissible states, this does not mean employers have unlimited authority to restrict employees. Courts usually still look at whether the agreement is reasonable and protects a legitimate business interest. Even though a state might not have a broad statutory ban, they may still have restrictions under its case law.

Some situations warrant using a non-compete in applicable states. When doing so, employers will want to have a well-drafted agreement that lists restricted activities and geographical area and can prove legitimate business interests as well as proper notice and consideration. They need to explain what they as the employer are trying to protect, like trade secrets, confidential business information, customer relationships, or specialized training. Simply wanting to prevent competition is generally not enough. Organizations should also consider a reasonable duration for enforcing the non-compete. Generally, the restriction should last only as long as reasonably necessary to protect the employer's legitimate interests. A six-month restriction may be appropriate in one situation, while a longer restriction may be difficult to justify in another. A strong non-compete agreement should identify a reasonable geographic area based on where the employer actually conducts business or has meaningful business relationships in which the non-compete will apply. It should also clearly identify the type of competitive work being restricted. Preventing an employee from performing substantially similar work for a direct competitor could be defensible however prohibiting any employment within an entire industry may not be permissible. Employers need to communicate these agreements to employees clearly and have them receive a copy and sign off. Some states require advance notice, a separate written agreement, additional compensation, or other consideration beyond continued employment. There is no universal formula for an enforceable non-compete. In addition to these best practices, employers must consider the applicable state's requirements and consult with legal counsel before using any standard agreement.

There are times employers take their non-competes too far and misuse them. The legal consequences for this can be severe and there are alternatives employers can and should consider. Employers should avoid using non-compete agreements for every employee. Requiring entry-level employees, administrative staff, or employees with no access to sensitive information to sign restrictive agreements, without a legitimate business justification could be a risky compliance decision. Non-competes should avoid overly broad restrictions that prevent former employees from working for any competitor, regardless of their position or responsibilities. It should also avoid excessive location restrictions which may lead to restricting an employment across an entire state or country when the employer only operates in a limited geographic area. Lastly, employers should never use non-competes as punishment and attempt to prevent employees from leaving for better opportunities. There are other ways to protect a business even when a non-compete is prohibited. To start, employers can make sure they have a strong onboarding and off boarding procedure and the appropriate access controls for sensitive company information. They can choose to implement a non-solicitation agreement which restricts soliciting former customers or employees. They could also have employees sign a Confidentiality or Non-Disclosure Agreement which would ensure repercussions for disclosing or misusing confidential information.

Using an overly restrictive or legally invalid non-compete agreement can create problems for employers. Potential consequences include a court refusing to enforce the agreement, so they cannot prevent the former employer from taking a job with a competitor. An employee could also bring a claim for damages or other relief causing financial strain on the organization which can be exacerbated by facing statutory penalties and attorney's fees in states that specifically authorize them. Additionally, government agencies may investigate employers that use non-competes in ways that unfairly restrict employees' ability to find work. Some states impose fines or other penalties simply for requiring employees to sign prohibited non-compete agreements, even if the employer never attempts to enforce them.

Employers may want to consider several other items as best practice. Periodically review your existing non-compete agreements, particularly if you operate in multiple states. An agreement that may have been enforceable several years ago may no longer comply with current law. Also keep in mind that an employee may live in one state, work remotely for an employer headquartered in another state, and service customers in several other states. Choice-of-law provisions do not necessarily allow employers to avoid another state's restrictions surrounding non-competes. Also consider whether you can enforce a non-compete when you terminate an employee without cause or lay off employees. Some states have additional restrictions in these circumstances. Due to multi-state compliance inconsistences like these, HR should work with legal counsel to determine whether a non-compete is actually necessary and the required components if so, or whether another restrictive agreement would accomplish the same thing.

Non-compete agreements can be useful tools for protecting legitimate business interests, but they are not a one-size-fits-all solution. As state laws continue to evolve, employers should take time to review their existing agreements and consider whether the restrictions are necessary, reasonable, and legally enforceable. HR professionals play an important role in helping employers balance business protection with employees' rights to pursue future career opportunities. Ultimately, a well-written agreement should protect what matters to the business without creating unnecessary legal risks or placing unreasonable limitations on employees.

 

Sources: americanbar.org; eig.org; foley.com

Filter:

Filter by Authors

Position your organization to THRIVE.

Become a Member Today